Overview
Our Lady of Consolation Nursing and Rehabilitative has a Medicare overall rating of 2 out of 5, below the New York average of 3.1. It is the only Medicare-rated nursing home in West Islip. It scores best on quality of care (4 of 5) and lowest on health inspections (2 of 5).
Residents receive about 3.8 hours of nursing care per day, more than at 66% of nursing homes in New York (the state average is 3.7 hours). Of that, 1.2 hours come from registered nurses.
Its most recent standard inspection, on July 2, 2025, found 16 health deficiencies, more than the New York average of 8.0. 5 of them came from complaint investigations. It has no fines on record for the past three years, while 31% of New York nursing homes have been fined.
Our Lady of Consolation Nursing and Rehabilitative is a nonprofit facility with 450 certified beds, caring for about 279 residents on an average day. It accepts both Medicare and Medicaid and has participated since 1975.
Medicare ratings
- Health inspections
- Quality of care
- Staffing
Source: Medicare Care Compare, data as of October 1, 2026.
How it compares nearby
Ranked by Medicare overall rating, then quality, inspection and staffing ratings.
Top 78%
Top 67%
Family reviews
No reviews yet. If your family has experience with Our Lady of Consolation Nursing and Rehabilitative, your review helps others decide.
Inspections and penalties
- Most recent standard inspection
- July 2, 2025
- Health deficiencies cited
- 16
- Complaint-related deficiencies
- 5
- Fines in the last 3 years
- 0
- Payment denials
- 0
- Total penalties
- 0
Staffing
Average hours of care each resident receives per day.
- All nursing staff3.78 hrs
- Registered nurses (RN)1.17 hrs
- Licensed practical nurses (LPN)0.44 hrs
- Nurse aides2.17 hrs
- Physical therapists0.27 hrs
Facility details
- Ownership
- Non profit - Corporation
- Certified beds
- 450
- Average residents per day
- 279
- Participates in
- Medicare and Medicaid
- Medicare/Medicaid since
- June 12, 1975
- Inside a hospital
- No
- Continuing care retirement community
- No
- Changed ownership in last 12 months
- No
- Resident or family council
- Both
- Sprinklers in all required areas
- Yes